Fifth Circuit Weighs In on DOL Fiduciary Rule

A panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has vacated the Department of Labor’s Fiduciary Rule. In a 2-1 split, the Fifth Circuit’s decision overrules a Dallas District Court’s decision, which had previously upheld the rule.

Unfortunately, the decision does little to settle the fate of the beleaguered rule. Although it is binding on the Fifth Circuit, which is comprised of Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, it is merely persuasive on the other circuits or until the Supreme Court weighs in. There’s also a chance that the Fifth Circuit will be asked to rehear the case en banc.

The lawsuit was originally brought by industry groups opposed to the rule, such as the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association. After failing to win at the district court level, the plaintiffs appealed to the Circuit court. The Fifth Circuit panel held, among other things, that the Department of Labor’s expansion of the applicability of the term “fiduciary” went beyond the Department’s authority.

We recall last decade when the SEC attempted to change the application of the word “client” to include private fund investors. In the Goldstein v. SEC decision, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit ruled that the SEC had exceed its authority in an attempt to require hedge fund managers to register. In the end, it took an act of Congress, also known as Dodd-Frank, to require private fund advisers to register, and expanded registration to private equity and other fund managers.

Between the Goldstein decision and Dodd-Frank, many registered managers did not de-register because the industry had come to expect money to be managed by the standards expressed by the SEC. Once the genie is out of the bottle, things change. Certainly, some of the concepts of the DOL Fiduciary Rule will remain with us in our compliance efforts to protect investors. Fortunately, we work with managers who value running strong businesses and we help them appropriately navigate these changing conditions without undue burden.

So  what does all of this mean for you? At the moment – not much. You should continue preparing for the Fiduciary Rule’s full implementation while continuing to monitor the Rule’s status.

Related Content

Latest Content

Placing Ethics and Compliance in the Foreground of Business Decision-Making

Thinking about how to make ethics and compliance part of a business’s decision-making can prove to be challenging. By nature, compliance professionals are often results-oriented, focusing on a binary end-result; either you are in compliance, or you are not. That focus is important, but emphasizing process is also vital, John Walsh, Partner at Eversheds Sutherland … Continued

What Am I Looking At? Making Sense of Your Cyber Testing Reports

It’s no surprise that Compliance and IT do not speak the same language. Compliance staff often speak in terms of regulations and policies, whereas bits and bytes are the language of IT staff. This distinction is clear when it comes to cybersecurity risk management, as the compliance and IT audiences are looking for different takeaways … Continued

It Takes a Village – Preparing for a Regulatory Exam

Advanced planning for a regulatory exam remains a vital step in ensuring the compliance team is prepared when the exam teams comes knocking. At the recent Ascendant/CSS fall conference in San Diego, Allison Fraser moderated the conference’s capstone session on the topic, joined by Bryan Bennett, the Associate Regional Director in the examination program in … Continued

The ‘Next Frontier’ in Investment Advice

We live in a world filled with dramatic change on a scale we’ve never seen before. The speed and magnitude of change in so many areas is fueled by technology. The sheer number of processes and functions we’re able to address simply from our phones has upended so many different industries, including travel, entertainment, and … Continued

Mailing List

Subscribe to the Ascendant Compliance email list for the latest compliance resources, conferences, ComplianceCasts™, and more.

Loading form...

Contact Us

Ascendant works together with clients to identify and assess critical needs through customized plans. If you need assistance with compliance functions, regulatory services, cybersecurity or technology tools, we’d love to speak with you.